
Started off as a 5, devolved to a 3.5. I was completed fascinated by this book in the beginning – a 16-year-old high school dropout guitar player whose mother abandoned her and a father who neglects her – picks up her shallow roots and moves to Ithaca, NY where she meets a veritable motley of quirky, fun characters. I felt like I was vicariously living April’s carefree life and just having fun, where I felt like I, too, fit in somewhere. Used to being homeless, though, April is incredibly commitment shy, but she slowly settles in and finds her place in the world where she can be her true self – that is, until she gets into a relationship with a guy and is scared stiff that he will find out she is only 16. So she runs away.
And this, then, becomes the pattern of the book. She barely lives gig to guitar gig, never staying in one place too long, but just long enough to build some close relationships until something goes wrong. She gets scared and runs to the next place. And the next place. And the next place.
I couldn’t help but imagine all the carnage of broken hearts that she left behind her, and that pained me so much. I wanted to feel for April, and at times I did because hurting people hurt people, but I also got very frustrated and angry that the people she left would have been really suffering, and there was no reconciliation for them.
At the end, the author ties everything up in a nice little bow with everyone that matters to April together in the same place, and hugs and kisses abound. I suppose I should be happy that it all worked out, but I am still miffed that it did, because those other poor souls were left abandoned by the author and by April, and they, I imagine, are left scarred. (I know they are fictional, but still!)
All in all, I still could not put this book down, and if April had stayed in Ithaca, I think it would have made for a much less frustrating, albeit not as predictable, story as The People We Keep.
